Trying to make sense of it

A visibly puzzled reaction to something that does not add up.

Source dimensions: 200 × 112 encoded pixels · 15 fps · 1.9 seconds
What it expresses: Two statements contradict each other or an explanation makes things less clear.
Example: Two statements contradict each other or an explanation makes things less clear.
When not to use it: A predictable consequence presented as a surprise.